"He knowingly misled my sister."
Does that mean he knew the woman was my sister?
Does that mean he knew the woman was my sister?
|
knowingly
"He knowingly misled my sister."
Does that mean he knew the woman was my sister?
How about this one?
"The biker deliberately ran down a mother of four." What did or didn't the biker know prior to the accident?
<<"He knowingly misled my sister."
Does that mean he knew the woman was my sister? >> <<Too little context. >> With such little context, the default interpretation would be that "He knew that he was misleading my sister" i.e. He intentionally misled her.
<With such little context, the default interpretation would be that "He knew that he was misleading my sister" i.e. He intentionally misled her.
> But your reply still doesn't state that he knew she was my sister, does it?
That sentence by itself doesn't imply anything about whether he knew she was your sister.
I agree with Rapp: the sentence implies that the misleading was a deliberate action, but it doesn't tell us whether or not he knew she was your sister.
<<<With such little context, the default interpretation would be that "He knew that he was misleading my sister" i.e. He intentionally misled her.
> But your reply still doesn't state that he knew she was my sister, does it? >> The "knowingly" goes with "misled"; not "my sister" For him to have known that she was your sister, the sentence would have to something like this: "Knowing she was my sister, he misled her" OR "He misled her, knowing that she was my sister"
<The "knowingly" goes with "misled"; not "my sister" >
And here? "She knowingly misled a policewoman."
<<And here?
"She knowingly misled a policewoman." >> Yes, there as well. Adverbs always modify verbs, not nouns. :-)
<Yes, there as well. Adverbs always modify verbs, not nouns. :-) >
They modify more than just verbs.
Adverbs modify verbs, adjectives, and other adverbs, right? "Sister" and "policewoman" are none of those.
|