fisher-king

MollyB   Thu Oct 18, 2007 4:27 pm GMT
Why doesn't a pail of water become heavier when a live fish is added to it?
Guest   Thu Oct 18, 2007 4:46 pm GMT
Because the fish drinks the water lol duh
Guest   Thu Oct 18, 2007 9:11 pm GMT
<Because the fish drinks the water lol duh >

Wrong answer. A pail of water does become heavier when a live fish is added to it?

Now which king asked and answered that, MollyB? I'm trying to recall.
MollyB   Thu Oct 18, 2007 10:01 pm GMT
Charles II
Guest   Fri Oct 19, 2007 12:33 am GMT
It does, the pail WILL become heavier...

MollyB, is there any reason for you to ask this question?? >.<
MollyB   Fri Oct 19, 2007 8:41 am GMT
MollyB, is there any reason for you to ask this question?? >.<

Yes, but it was a bit of a red herring, no pun intended.

It was first asked by Charles II.

Here's the story and my reason for posting the question:

"There is a story that when Charles II founded the Royal Society, he asked its scientists to explain to him why a pail of water does not become heavier when a live fish is added to it. After the scientists eventually confessed themselves baffled, the king roared with laughter and pointed out that in fact the pail does become heavier."

http://www.grsampson.net/AGwg.html

The point in the linked article was that we often believe the conclusions of prescriptive grammarians without checking whether the comments they make are true or not.